Loyola’s Second Annual Symposium on Digital Ethics
Lindsay Blauvelt, SOC Website Reporter
October, 2012--It used to be children who set a place at the dinner table for their imaginary friends but in the world of digital technology there is a permanent place for SIRI at supper and she’s got the seat of honor.
Loyola’s second annual Symposium on Digital Ethics on Monday brought scholars of all kinds together to ask the questions that have arisen in the wake of a technological revolution that has put cell phones at the table and televisions in the bedroom.
The event, hosted by the Center for Digital Ethics, featured panels on topics like privacy, moral agency, technology in the classroom and keynote speaker Sherry Turkle, who spoke on the ethical implications of welcoming these high-tech companions into everyday life.
Turkle is the Current Director of the MIT Initiative on Technology and Self and has done extensive research on the newly emerging relationships between humans and their robotic counterparts. While naming these technologies as equals may be a bit extreme, Turkle’s presentation amply illustrated the increasingly intimate between man and machine.
Turkle said, “In my research one woman came up to me and said, ‘I really wouldn’t mind having a robot boyfriend, I just want some stability in my home, it’s okay with me that it’s not a real relationship.’'
It may seem a bit comical, however it’s closer to reality than may be expected. Just ten years ago, cell phones were still a growing trend. Now they sit on the nightstand because they can serve as an alarm clock, a nightlight and can fetch the weather report in the morning. But the real question here is whether or not it has impacted humans on a deeper level than making the morning commute a little more convenient.
“The ethical issues around that question are now coming to a very dramatic point because now we’re making machines that can actually pretend to feel,” Turkle said. “The older machines pretended to think and now they’re pretending to feel.”
Turkle referred to new technology like SIRI, the robotic secretary that comes standard on the iPhone 4S and is programmed to give surprisingly human responses to questions about her biography.
“The way I see it, we are tempted by technology that offers the allusion of companionship without the demands of friendship,” Turkle said. “We’re asking more from technology than we are from each other. That’s not a comfortable human position; it’s not a comfortable ethical position.”
Examples from her research, including teens with separation anxiety from their phones, aptly demonstrated Turkle’s concern for the increasingly intermingled relationship.
“Do we deserve to be talking about these meaningful, important moments in our lives with something that can understand what it is to know loss, what it is to know life, ”Turkle asked. “Or are we content to play games at these key human moments?”
For older generations these notions of robot friends are parts of a science fiction novel. But for those ‘90s kids that grew up with Tamagotchis and baby dolls that can speak, it’s all a part of normal life.
Don Heider, Dean of the School of Communication and founder of the Center for Digital Ethics, said that the purpose of the center is to encourage discussions and research like Turkle’s work, but also to bridge the gap between the technology and the ways that it is used.
“The technology develops before our ability to make good decisions about it does,” Heider said. “So we have the technology and a few years later we think, was this a good idea? So we’re trying to close that gap a bit.”
For students especially, the idea of digital security is extremely important, as it’s common practice for employers to look at Facebook profiles and Google searches of potential employees.
“I think it’s great that the students come in as freshman and sophomores and they can start to think about some of these questions,” Heider said. “I think it has a really positive influence.”
Turkle added that it’s not just about being responsible users of technology, but using it in a way that maintains a sense of humanity.
“Why are we here? In terms of not just information but in terms of human experience, experience that motivates us, inspires us, makes us identify with our teacher; experience that makes us feel as though we’re passing down a legacy or the recipients of a legacy.”
More Featured Stories
Ignatian HeritageRethink what your responsibility is to the truth. That was the message Fr. Jon Sobrino, S.J., wanted to pass on Thursday night to an auditorium packed with Loyola students, faculty, staff, and others in the Chicago community.
QuinlanTwo Quinlan teams, composed mostly of undergraduate students, took home two out of three awards at one of the nation's largest data analytics and technology conferences. “Our teams presented flawlessly,” said Professor Nenad Jukić, who served as the coach.
HistoryThe History Department of Loyola University Chicago commemorates the 25th anniversary of the Jesuit martyrs of El Salvador through the launch of the public history project, “The Ellacuría Tapes: A Martyr at Loyola.”
PodcastHear newly installed Archbishop Blase Cupich discuss his first week in Chicago on Relevant Radio, hosted by Fr. Greg Sakowicz of St. Mary Parish in Evanston and Wayne Magdziarz, Vice President and Chief of Staff for the President's Office at Loyola.
AthleticsSteve Watson was named the new athletics director at Loyola on November 12. Watson, a former Division 1 student-athlete who played professional basketball overseas, comes to Loyola from St. Bonaventure University. “(Loyola) is a great school, in a great city, with great people,” Watson said.
Student spotlightLoyola senior David Lewis is a busy man. He’s a member of numerous student groups and is also pursuing a double major, along with two minors. On November 1, Lewis added one more item to his growing resume: Loyola’s 2014 Lincoln Academy of Illinois Student Laureate.
In the newsDean Darrell Wheeler, PhD, of the School of Social Work was recently named one of the 30 most influential social workers alive today. Selection was based on merit, scholastic study, and political activism.
In the newsQuinlan hosted a special event this fall on campus, bringing together leaders from the governmental, nonprofit, and corporate sectors to come up with solutions to food deserts in Chicago
Staff spotlightAnita Lumpkin, who served for 10 years in the Army Reserves before getting her master’s degree in higher education administration, brings a unique background to her post as coordinator of Loyola’s new office of Military Veteran Student Services.
ResearchLoyola psychology professor Grayson Holmbeck has been studying children with spina bifida for more than 20 years. In that time, he says: “We’ve learned a lot about what their problems and issues are, what we can do to help them, and more importantly, what they’re capable of.”
Adult LearnersStarting in 2015, Loyola will offer several FASTRACK degree programs for adult learners at its Cuneo Mansion & Gardens in Vernon Hills. Courses will be on alternating Saturdays with an online component—perfect for anyone looking to balance work, life, and school.
Professor profileQuinlan Professor Nenad Jukić was named Loyola’s Faculty Member of the Year on September 14 as part of the University’s Faculty Convocation. This latest award caps off a string of impressive accolades for Jukić, who also was named Quinlan’s Outstanding Undergraduate Teacher of the Year.
Helping othersFour Loyola graduate students were recently selected for the prestigious Albert Schweitzer Fellowship program and will spend the next year working on healthcare-related projects to help underserved communities in Chicago.
AcademicsLoyola is one of just 283 universities to have a Phi Beta Kappa chapter, a claim that only about 10 percent of the nation’s colleges can make.
SustainabilityLoyola is ranked No. 4 on the Sierra Club’s 2014 list of the greenest colleges in America. The annual rankings are designed to spotlight universities that are deeply committed to environmental responsibility.
In the newsLoyola’s Information Commons joins an elite group of peers on Business Insider’s list of the “coolest” college libraries in the country.
ExploreThe Institute of Environmental Sustainability combines academics and research with agriculture and community living—all in one facility.
Damen CenterThe Damen Center was designed from top to bottom with students in mind, making it the center of social life on Loyola’s Lake Shore Campus.